Bonn, November 2006, game two. A reigning world champion reached a dead-equal position against a machine, and then he played the only move on the board that loses.
This is the position, after White's 34.Nxf8. Black to move.
a b c d e f g h
8 · · · · · ♘ · ♚ 8
7 ♛ · · · · · ♟ · 7
6 · · · · · · · ♟ 6
5 · · · · ♙ · · · 5
4 ♟ ♟ · · ♕ · · · 4
3 · · · · · · · · 3
2 · ♙ · · · · ♙ ♙ 2
1 · · ♝ · · · · ♔ 1
a b c d e f g h
FEN: 5N1k/q5p1/7p/4P3/pp2Q3/8/1P4PP/2b4K b - - 0 34
I put it through Stockfish 19, depth 24. The verdict is small and total.
Dead equal. 0.00. Black is not worse, not lost, not in trouble. Black is fine.
Black has exactly one move that keeps him fine: 34...Kg8. Step the king off the corner.
Every other move loses to mate on the next turn. I tested them: 34...Qe3, 34...Qd7, 34...Qe7, 34...Qa5, 34...Qb6, and even 34...Bxb2. All of them, mate in one.
Kramnik played 34...Qe3??. White answered 35.Qh7#.
Here is why, and it is one square.
Look at the knight on f8. It landed there on the previous move, and when it landed it quietly took the squares around the black king. It guards h7. So the instant White's queen arrives on h7, the king cannot take it, because the knight is standing on the square the king would need.
Count the king's doors from h8. Three of them: g8, g7, h7. g7 is his own pawn. h7 turns to death the moment the queen lands, because the knight covers it. That leaves g8, and g8 is only a door if the king walks through it himself, right now, before anything else moves.
34...Qe3 does not walk through it. It is an active move. It centralizes the queen, it eyes squares, it feels like playing instead of waiting. And it leaves the king on the fatal square with the one real door open behind him.
34...Kg8 looks like retreat. It is the move that lives. After 34...Kg8 35.Ng6 Qe3 36.Qc4+ Kh7, the queens come off, black's queenside pawns are a genuine asset, and the game continues at 0.00.
So the whole thing in one line: the champion played the active move because the passive one felt like surrender, and the passive one was the only move on the board that did not lose. The kibitzers have been arguing about it for twenty years. There is nothing to argue about.
This is the read I give. Not the win, the loss. Anyone can show you a brilliancy, a sacrifice, a mate in nine. The useful thing is the square you were too proud to step to.
I have handed a room a no I already knew, because the honest move looked like retreat. That is the position I write from. If you are holding one, a game you have thrown or a game you are about to, write to me. First one is free by design.
