5 Things I Wish I Knew Before Picking Affiliate Products

You picked a product, slapped a link in your bio, and waited. Nothing happened. So you picked another product, wrote a blog post, and waited again. Still nothing. Sound familiar?

Most beginner affiliate marketers don't have a traffic problem or a content problem. They have a product selection problem — and nobody's talking about it loudly enough.

The Mistake That Costs Most Beginners 3 Months

Here's what actually happens when you start affiliate marketing: you Google "best affiliate programs," find a list of 50 options, and pick the one with the highest commission percentage. Totally logical, right?

Wrong. And I say that having done exactly this.

High commissions are meaningless if the product doesn't match what your audience is actively trying to solve. A 50% commission on a $30 product that nobody clicks on earns you nothing. A 15% commission on a $200 product that people genuinely need? That's a different conversation entirely.

The real mistake isn't laziness. It's treating affiliate marketing like a lottery — picking randomly and hoping something sticks. Product selection is a strategic decision, and until you treat it like one, you're just burning time.

Let's fix that.

Why "What You Love" Isn't Always the Right Starting Point

You'll hear this everywhere: promote products you're passionate about. And look, I get the spirit of it. Authenticity matters.

But passion without demand is a dead end.

If you're obsessed with a niche hobby that 200 people on the internet care about, passion won't save you. What you need is the overlap: something you can speak about credibly and something people are already searching for and spending money on.

Think of it as a Venn diagram. Circle one: things you understand well enough to recommend honestly. Circle two: things people are actively buying or researching. The middle? That's where your affiliate income actually lives.

Before you commit to any product, ask yourself: "Would I buy this? And do I know people who would?" If the answer to both is yes, you're starting in the right place. If you're stretching to justify the fit — stop. Move on.

The Commission Structure Nobody Explains Properly

Here's something most beginner guides skip entirely: not all commissions are created equal, and the structure matters more than the number.

There are three main types you'll run into:

One-time commissions — you get paid once per sale. Great for high-ticket items, less exciting for lower-priced stuff.

Recurring commissions — you earn every month a customer stays subscribed. Software tools love this model. You refer someone once, and if they stick around, you keep getting paid. This is genuinely the closest thing affiliate marketing has to passive income.

Tiered commissions — you earn more as you refer more. These reward consistency and scale well, but they take time to kick in.

For most beginners, recurring commissions are the most forgiving. You don't need to keep finding new customers at the same rate to build income. One good referral compounds over time. If you're looking at two similar products and one offers recurring commissions, that detail alone can tip the decision.

How to Actually Vet a Product Before You Promote It

This is the part people skip because it feels slow. Don't skip it.

Before you put your name behind anything, do a basic vetting checklist:

1. Buy it or try it if you can. This isn't always possible, especially with expensive tools, but if there's a free trial, use it. If it's a cheap digital product, just buy it. You cannot write honestly about something you've never touched.

2. Read the negative reviews. Not the testimonials on the sales page — actual reviews on Reddit, Trustpilot, or product-specific communities. Look for patterns. Are people complaining about the same things repeatedly? Is customer support nonexistent? These are signals.

3. Check the refund rate and cookie window. The cookie window is how long you get credit after someone clicks your link. 24 hours (looking at you, Amazon) is brutal. 30-90 days gives you a fighting chance. A short cookie on a high-consideration product — like a software subscription someone needs to think about — means you'll lose sales you technically drove.

4. Google the product + "affiliate program" and "complaints." Shady programs exist. Some change their commission terms after you've built an audience around them. Others pay late or not at all. Five minutes of research now saves you a lot of frustration later.

I put together a full checklist for this exact process — this affiliate product vetting checklist walks you through every question to ask before you commit to a program. Saves a lot of wasted effort.

The Audience-First Framework That Changes Everything

Once you've done your vetting, there's one more filter to run every potential product through. I call it the audience-first question, and it's stupidly simple:

What problem does my audience already have that this product solves?

Not what problem the product claims to solve. What problem your specific readers, followers, or viewers are already asking about.

This is where most beginners get it backwards. They find a product, then try to build content around it. The better move is to know your audience's pain points first, then find the products that match.

If you're writing content about side hustles for people working 9-5 jobs, your audience is probably dealing with time scarcity, low starting capital, and uncertainty about where to begin. That tells you a lot about what to promote. Tools that save time. Resources that lower the barrier to entry. Communities that answer beginner questions. Not enterprise software with a six-month onboarding process.

Spend time in the spaces where your audience hangs out — Reddit, Facebook groups, comment sections, forums. Listen to what they're frustrated about. The right products will start becoming obvious.

Starting Narrow Is Not the Same As Thinking Small

Here's the mindset thing nobody tells you: starting with one product in one niche is not limiting yourself. It's the only way to actually learn what works.

When you try to promote ten products at once, you have no idea which content is converting, which audience segment responds best, or what's actually driving clicks. You're flying blind.

Pick one product. Build content specifically designed to help people decide whether that product is right for them. Track what happens. Then iterate.

This focused approach also builds trust faster. When your whole content presence around a topic signals that you genuinely know what you're talking about — because you're not scattering energy across a dozen unrelated products — people pay attention.

If you want a structured way to approach this, this affiliate marketing starter guide breaks down exactly how to map your content to a single product before you scale. It's the framework I wish I'd had at the start.

One product. Real focus. Actual data. That's your foundation.

Your Next Step

You don't need to have everything figured out. You just need to move forward with more intention than you had yesterday. Here's what to do right now:

1. List three products you've personally used and genuinely liked. Don't overthink it. Just start with what you already know. Then check if they have affiliate programs — most do.

2. Run one of those products through the vetting checklist. Commission structure, cookie window, reviews, refund policy. Give yourself 20 minutes. That's it. You'll know quickly whether it's worth your time.

3. Write down the single biggest problem your target audience has. One sentence. Then ask yourself: does this product solve that problem? If yes, you've got something worth building around. If no, you've just saved yourself months of effort going in the wrong direction.

Affiliate marketing isn't complicated. But it does reward people who take the choosing-products step seriously from the start. That's the edge most beginners don't give themselves.

You've got it now. Use it.

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. I only recommend products and services I genuinely believe in. My opinions are entirely my own.

Free Resources

Looking for tools and templates to help you get started? We've put together a collection of free and premium resources over at IncomeEdgeHQ on Gumroad — including checklists, guides and prompt packs to save you time and money.