Sotion vs NotionMember vs HelpKit (2026 comparison)

If you're a creator selling digital products from your Notion workspace — courses, paid newsletters, member communities, premium guides — you've probably hit the same wall I did. Notion is a beautiful CMS. Notion is not a paywall.

Three tools dominate the conversation when you Google "Notion paywall" in 2026: Sotion, NotionMember, and HelpKit. All three have been around long enough to have real customers and real reviews. None of them solves the problem completely.

I spent two weeks running these tools through their paces with the same use case: a creator selling three digital products (a course, an ebook, a paid community) from one Notion workspace. Here's what each is actually good at, what they're missing, and how to pick.

The 30-second answer

• Sotion — best if you want the most established membership-platform features (custom CSS, API webhooks, Zapier) and you're OK paying $7-97/mo.
• NotionMember — best if you only need a simple paywall, want to keep your own Stripe, and want the cheapest entry tier ($15/mo Pro).
• HelpKit — not actually a paywall product. It's a knowledge-base tool that also has a paywall feature as a side effect. Best for documentation-style content; awkward for paid newsletters or courses.

Past those three, there's a fourth thing to consider: none of them have AI-driven conversion optimization, none have integrated email funnels, and all three punt the actual payment relationship to your Stripe account (or Lemon Squeezy, or Gumroad — your problem to integrate). I'll come back to that gap at the end.

What each tool actually does

Sotion (sotion.app)

Sotion is the most mature of the three. As of late 2025 they have 3,000+ sites and 450+ paying users. Pricing tiers from $7/mo Basic to $97/mo Elite, with an annual discount of 20%.

What you get:

• Convert any Notion page into a member-only site at a custom domain
• Multiple access methods: password, email signup whitelist, paid memberships (via Stripe / Lemon Squeezy / Gumroad)
• Custom CSS and JavaScript injection
• API and webhook access on Pro tier and up
• Built-in SEO metadata customization

Where Sotion shines:

• The most feature-complete option if you want a "membership site builder" experience
• The custom CSS/JS escape hatch is genuinely useful when default styling doesn't fit your brand
• API access (Pro+) lets you hook member events into Zapier or Make for automation

Where Sotion falls short:

• Payment processing is your problem. Sotion handles authentication; you bring your own Stripe + Stripe Tax + handle disputes + handle VAT compliance. For a solo creator, that's three additional vendors to manage.
• No AI features for conversion optimization. The signup form you ship is the signup form forever, unless you A/B test manually.
• No email automation. Member signup → silence (unless you bolted on ConvertKit or similar).
• No cross-product analytics. If you sell three products, you have three Sotion sites and three sets of analytics that don't talk to each other.

NotionMember (notionmember.com)

NotionMember is the budget-friendly entry. Free up to 10 members, $15/mo Pro for 3 protected sites with unlimited members and custom domain, $39/mo Team for unlimited sites.

What you get:

• Magic-link email sign-in (no passwords to manage)
• Add or remove members instantly via a dashboard
• Real-time sync — changes in Notion reflect on the member site within seconds
• Custom domain support
• Page-level access control (protect specific pages, not just whole sites)

Where NotionMember shines:

• Cheapest tier in the category if you have <10 members (free) or modest scale (Pro $15/mo)
• Magic link UX is friction-free for end-users
• Page-level granularity is more flexible than Sotion's site-level model

Where NotionMember falls short:

• Same payment story as Sotion — bring your own Stripe / Lemon Squeezy / etc. for the actual money flow
• Same lack of AI features
• Same lack of email automation
• Less mature than Sotion (smaller feature set, smaller community)
• No cross-product analytics

HelpKit (helpkit.so)

HelpKit is sometimes lumped into the "Notion paywall" conversation but it's a different product. HelpKit's primary positioning is knowledge base / help center built from Notion — think Intercom Help Center but powered by your Notion workspace. The paywall is a side feature.

What you get:

• AI-powered search across your Notion-sourced KB (a real differentiator)
• Embeddable widget that drops into your existing site
• Faster sync than competitors (per their marketing)
• Paywall via Lemonsqueezy integration (their MoR partner)
• Analytics on what users searched for (also a real differentiator)

Where HelpKit shines:

• If your "paid content" is documentation, tutorials, or any structured KB-style content, HelpKit is the cleanest fit
• AI search is genuinely useful for users who want to find a specific answer fast
• The Lemonsqueezy MoR partnership means HelpKit handles VAT compliance for you (rare in this category)

Where HelpKit falls short:

• Awkward fit for non-KB content. Selling a paid newsletter? Selling a course with structured lessons? HelpKit's KB-first information architecture works against you.
• The paywall flow feels secondary, because it is secondary in HelpKit's product priorities
• Less control over branding than Sotion's custom CSS approach

Side-by-side

Which one to pick

Pick Sotion if: you're running a creator membership site with multiple types of content (videos, posts, downloads), you want maximum control over look-and-feel, and you're OK building your own Stripe + analytics + email stack alongside.

Pick NotionMember if: you have a single Notion site, you want the cheapest option that works, and you don't need API/webhook automation. Good for someone running a single paid newsletter archive or members-only blog.

Pick HelpKit if: your paywalled content is fundamentally a knowledge base (structured docs, tutorials, course library) and you want the AI search that sets HelpKit apart. Don't pick it for newsletters or community-style content.

What none of them solve

Run through what a real solo creator selling digital products from Notion actually needs end-to-end:

1. Lead capture forms with conversion optimization
2. Paywall with multiple pricing tiers
3. Payment processing with global VAT/tax compliance
4. Email funnels for nurture and reactivation
5. A/B testing of headlines, CTAs, prices
6. Cross-product analytics (visits → email → trial → paid → renewal)
7. Cohort and segmentation insights for retention
8. Audit of WHY customers churn

Sotion + NotionMember + HelpKit collectively handle ~40% of this. The other 60% is your problem — solve it by gluing together ConvertKit ($29/mo), Stripe Tax ($35/mo+ at scale), Plausible ($9/mo), Posthog free tier, and a bunch of Zapier connections.

For one product, that's maybe manageable. For three products, you're managing eight subscriptions and three different "source of truth" data stores.

This stack-of-tools-glued-together is the pain that prompted me to build The InnerRoom — a single tool that combines Notion paywall + AI-optimized lead capture + built-in payments (via Polar's MoR for global tax compliance) + email funnels + cross-product analytics. Same buyer, sharper integration. Drop your email if you want the launch update.

What about pricing comparison?

Here's the math at the "selling three digital products" use case:

Sotion + ConvertKit + Stripe Tax + Plausible:

• Sotion Pro: $37/mo
• ConvertKit Creator: $29/mo
• Stripe Tax: ~$35/mo at $10k/mo revenue
• Plausible: $9/mo
• Total: ~$110/mo, plus the time cost of integration

HelpKit + ConvertKit + Plausible (if KB-suitable content):

• HelpKit (mid-tier): ~$49/mo
• ConvertKit Creator: $29/mo
• Plausible: $9/mo
• Total: ~$87/mo, lower because HelpKit bundles MoR

NotionMember + Stripe + ConvertKit + Plausible:

• NotionMember Pro: $15/mo
• ConvertKit Creator: $29/mo
• Plausible: $9/mo (Stripe is per-transaction, not per-month)
• Total: ~$53/mo, but you're managing more pieces

Add email automation tooling (Sendgrid, Customer.io, etc.) and you're at $80-150/mo across 4-5 vendors regardless of which paywall you start with.

Bottom line

For 2026, all three tools work for what they're for. Pick the one that matches your content shape:

• Membership site with custom branding → Sotion
• Simple paid blog/newsletter → NotionMember
• Knowledge base / docs / structured tutorials → HelpKit

But also know what you're committing to: the paywall is one piece of a larger stack. The vendors are real. The integration is real work. The cross-product visibility you'll wish you had isn't there.

If you've felt that pain and you're tired of the duct-taped stack, I'd love to hear about it. Drop your email at innerroom.dev — I'm building the bundled version and shipping early access soon.

Want updates as I publish more posts like this? Subscribe to the early-access list at innerroom.dev. I write about the creator tooling landscape from the perspective of building the next-gen tool, not selling the current one.